They are harder to upgrade or roll back than the front end of a website and so are more amenable to up-front design than continual refinement. The latter places an emphasis on up-front design, documentation, and completeness, to create a safety net that can produce mission-critical, complex software in a small number of releases. Automate your build process with your test process and with a developer check-in. In other words, integration tests check code changes to make sure they don’t break other parts of a system. Currently available on Amazon, in paperback and Kindle versions.- all royalties go to Computers 4 Africa. Face-to-face communication is high bandwidth. The key goal is to aim for a steady, sustainable pace. This gives them the time to work with developers, Project Managers and testers to make the databases more stable overall. A simple PowerShell script can run a set of scripts against a test database and capture the runtime of each query. Writing tests first forces you to think about different ways your code can fail. And their extensive use of automation for things like building and testing causes their level of risk to decrease, as shown in Figure 1. Changing a data type, however, can result in SQL Server checking every row, to make sure existing data does not violate the new data type. Instead of having people manage each step of the process, teams must look for ways to create fully automated pipelines that submit cha… Here is my recommendation to help you extend your automation. If someone checks in code that fails one of these tests, they get an email automatically, warning them of their peril. Database development teams, however, use it differently, if they use it. The emphasis of the test is on integration points; each test creates/modifies data in every application in the system architecture. A core of Agile development is communication, and preferably co-location. No longer can the App DBA do their work from the “DBA Cave”. We should treat them in the same way, and apply the same standards of quality to their design, deployment and testing. The product roadmap is a high-level view of the product requirements with a loose time frame for when to develop those requirements. Another pillar of robust deployments: always have a rollback mechanism to undo the changes made to your database during a deployment, and return the database schema and objects to their predeployment state. Triggers in particular are a double-edged sword; their hidden nature and support of complexity can lead to unexpected problems. Features being equal, a simpler design is easier to fix and extend than a complex design. Agile principles emerged in an attempt to correct this, proposing instead: Without rigidly enforcing specific practices, agile embodies the best of these principles to more quickly deliver better software. Getting developers and testers to use the same set of tests and testing tools is the most important step. In my experience, development teams don’t run database performance tests as often as they should, mainly because running them can require a near-copy of production hardware and they don’t have the IT resources or budget to do that. It requires good judgement and leaves little room for error. Automated testing provides a basis and a safety net for accelerating database deployments because it offers nearly immediate assurance that new changes do not break earlier work. Good judgment, smart people, lots of communication, and a level head are what you really need. Database testing is the third component of DDT. Although most application developers now consider DevOps a mainstream approach, database developers — especially those working on relational databases — have been slower to embrace it because of the need to understand and respect the state of a database when deploying changes. Oracle has acquired Agile, a leading provider of product lifecycle management (PLM) software solutions. More and more software development teams use “Agile” methods. We catch any test failures instantly, and can notify the developer(s) responsible. One big change with a switch to Agile is a dramatic decrease in documentation. For example, it’s a wise practice to set aside 10-20% of development time to pay the “maintenance tax,” in other words, reduce technical debt and fix operational bugs. I have found them to be particularly important when working on a database without enough interfaces, or when changing an interface. Agile teams deploy anywhere between once a week, to ten times a day, a pace unthinkable in a Waterfall environment. It calls for modeling, developing and constantly evolving the architecture of an IT component, system or infrastructure from the ground up, using agile techniques. If your deployment fails at Step 4, you can restart it from Steps 1, 2, or 3 without worry. Developers subject their code to peer review to ensure that they haven't missed something, introduced a security vulnerability, made a mistake in logic or inadvertently slowed the product down. Why have they been slower to adopt DevOps practices and shorter development cycles? With a smooth-running Agile team, a development task that involves the database may turn a programming pair into a programming trio. Consider a team of five people working on database code changes. Another common task is to remove an unneeded column. Use patterns. They store the data and enable data integrity. Be realistic about your goals. Rather than "when not all the requirements are known", we can say "How should I be designing an Agile database that will change in the future". I worked in a team where developers who broke the build had to bring in donuts for everyone. Automated validation tests can help guard against some aspects of poor database design. This is particularly bad for databases because they often support multiple applications and, unless we take the time to design proper interfaces, database-refactoring can happen only when all coupled applications can change, meaning it happens at the pace of the slowest application team. The best way to ensure accurate data is to use a clean and simple data model. Automate your monitoring alerts to trigger your maintenance processes (and vice versa). The first is defensive: I don’t want to do this. Make sure it has a rollback mode. Relieving that bottleneck requires an automated pipeline with which database development teams can address risk, ensure quality and shorten the development cycle for the organization as a whole. Their working lives becomes faster, less certain, and with more change. Keep your design as simple as possible. The most important objects in a database are its tables. That way, we can deploy either application or database on their own, without any dependencies. Agile leaves little room for error; it requires good judgment. Thus, automating the process at the database development level can reduce the time the team spends and increase overall consistency of code reviews. DevOps, Continuous Delivery & Database Lifecycle Management For a large table, the way to add a column with minimal user impact is to add it as a NULLable column. MongoDB’s dynamic schema easily adapts and evolves along with your application. Given the extreme pressure and ever-tightening deadlines of the database development cycle, many teams rush the code review process or skip it entirely. The way we design databases has performance implications. With a database that is impossible, because dropping and re-creating a database drops all of the information, negating its raison d’être. To protect the data contained in the database, database developers and DBAs must manage its state through scripting that gracefully updates the database from one state to another. What about agile database development? When doing performance testing, define fast enough and scales enough before you test. This can be a benefit; thorough documentation is always out of date and rarely used. The Manifesto was developed by a group fourteen leading figures in the software industry, and reflects their experience of what approaches do and do not work for software development. Keep releases decoupled, so that you can deploy them independently of other deployments, such as application deployments. The early stages of Agile adoption often take a heavy toll on software engineers. That way you can change the two independently. To shorten the cycle to two weeks, they add two or three developers, for a total of seven or eight. Data is a corporate asset and need… For example, we can create validation checks based on querying the system views to look for tables without primary keys, foreign keys without indexes, tables without abstraction views, or objects without permissions, and so on. Unless you are telepathic, the fastest way is speaking in person. For DBAs, constant communication makes it easy to keep developers in the loop about production issues. Our team usually tries to run performance tests at least once per release, especially for changes to large or critical systems. For example, if we make a change to the database, we should run integration tests to ensure we didn’t break any applications or services that use the database. As a simple example, instead of having a script that runs: Our scripts should first check for the object’s existence. Dropping an index is a quick operation, but creating or altering (rebuilding) an index often requires significant processing time. In … To roll back a new table, drop it. Turn them into database design-validation tests, and make sure they run every time you check in a change. In order for all of the team to keep up with this pace, and still understand the system and where it is heading, they must communicate all…of…the…time. This is a continuous build system. Using software tools in a piecemeal fashion is faster than purely manual processes, but it provides only incremental improvements. Once your organization becomes convinced of the advantages of database DevOps, there's no going back. DDT kills bugs. Key-value tables are notoriously painful because they force the application to handle data integrity. In addition, we can identify quickly which changes we need to deploy in order to advance the production database to the current version. Having said that, data is only one part of the overall picture. Figure 5: Cost of fixing bugs at various stages of software delivery. Other types of interfaces are Object Relational Mapping (ORM) and client-side tools. I use the SIIP approach to database design: Simplicity, Integrity, Interfaces, and Patterns. And this is what I want to explain here - the nature of the challenge of Agile Database Design. Facilitates frequent database refreshes in support of alternative environments (DEV, TEST etc. One of the principles that agile organizations follow is to deliver working software frequently, from a couple of weeks to a couple of months, with a preference to the shorter timescale. Close collaboration between the programmer team and business experts, Frequent delivery of new, deployable business value, Ways to craft the code and the team such that the inevitable requirements churn was not a crisis. For development work, I like to have a single-command build-and-test script. The last common requirement is to add a column to a table and load it with data. Database development teams will never scale to the speed required to keep up with agile application development teams unless they introduce software automation into their processes as well. Beyond that, there are data integrity implications in our choice of nullability, defaults, and the use of triggers. The key is to make this “automation work” a part of your daily routine. The integration of Agile management into database administration changes many things, especially in terms of what a DBA will be expected to do. If something fails three times, the same way, they automate it. Generally, making a column bigger is a metadata-only, quick change. This technique also keeps the object permissions in place and we can use it for views, functions, triggers, i.e. As disruptive as this is, it's necessary to resolve the business issue. It is impossible to change an index definition using ALTER INDEX. This, coupled with the rapid rate of change of the system design means that people, rather than documents, become the primary source of domain knowledge. Dev is a data geek, developer, and aspiring polymath. Does not include Agile Vault Repositories or live transactions that have not been committed to the database. Agile works very well if you do the right things. Agile database development is particularly hard because databases contain state and must ensure data integrity. Just in case, make sure your application fails gracefully if the table isn’t there. Make sure you can enforce patterns automatically. Excellent tools exist for application developers; database developers, if sufficiently inspired by the agile mentality, can adopt them for use in their projects as well. The first tenet of database deployments: make them robust. Without documentation, the code, including the tests, is the documentation. Possibly, but 10 or 11 developers working on the same code base makes for a lot of cooks in the kitchen, especially at such a breakneck pace. In that situation, the table schema is tightly coupled to the applications themselves, and cannot be changed without coordinating the change among application teams. In many cases, the production DBA will have to make the change and apply it directly to the live production environment with minimal, usually rushed testing (see Figure 2). What if you could relieve your database bottleneck, reduce application release time and spend less time fixing defects? The dynamic SQL approach can get messy for anything beyond a very simple stored procedure; the previously referenced article by Alexander Karmanov describes an elegant alternative approach using SET NOEXEC ON/OFF: For indexes, the choice is different. Fortnightly newsletters help sharpen your skills and keep you ahead, with articles, ebooks and opinion to keep you informed. The exception is if a table isn’t yet in use by applications, in which case there is minimal user impact. The number of deployments increases, requiring investment in streamlined deployment practices. The third reaction is the sensible reaction: I can do this, but only with help. Spoken language is very efficient; we can convey about 150-200 words per minute, which is 2-4 times faster than we can type. Control carefully who has permissions to make database modifications. Unfortunately, these are not the typical results for “early stage” Agile adopters. In addition, allow a fixed, reasonable amount of deployment time per week. ). Adding five to 10 more people — even if they could find and afford them — would almost certainly result in chaos and significantly more management overhead than progress. But the database team must manually walk changes through a much longer cycle. Agile requires a fundamental shift in the way teams work. Agile software development can be broken down into several methodologies, such as Scrum and XP (Extreme Programming). It is acceptable to install multiple server components on the same computer if the additional resources are not Still, in the world of application development, a single-day cycle is not extraordinary. This prevents me from checking in a broken build or failed unit test at least once per new feature. Traditional software development methods rely on deep specification, design, documentation and months or years of heads-down work to deliver a product. Agile for all industries – not just Software Introduction. Every time a developer checks in a change, build the code and run a set of unit tests against it. Without agile, changes of any kind go through the database development cycle much more slowly. The best way to acquire this skill is through experience. There are many different ways to communicate. it impacts one of the 20 biggest tables in a database, it impacts one of the 20 most-commonly-queried tables in a database, it impacts tables/databases that are used by several different applications, it changes permissions, or requires odd permissions, it deletes data from a database via DDL (for example, dropping a column or a table), it uses an uncommon piece of the database engine (, Copyright 1999 - 2020 Red Gate Software Ltd. Using software tools in a piecemeal fashion each step of the way is faster than pure manual processes, but it provides only incremental improvements. You need to be twice as smart to troubleshoot a system as you do to build one. However, we can automate or streamline many of these tasks. Culture and Organization. The Agile 9.3.3 database installer generates a shell script agile9postupgrade.bat/sh that can be run after upgrading the Agile PLM schema with AUT. To increase the number of deployments, the team needs to automate and streamline the deployment process to reduce time and risk, or they need more DBAs! An Agile DBA is expected to do the following: Weak or counter-intuitive designs lead to anarchy. a database is used by multiple applications. But because business requirements and customer landscape often change while all that work is under way, the company ends up launching its product into a very different market and missing the mark. Database developers often use patterns to ensure a set of consistent naming conventions and data type standards. Build a script that can deploy a single set of changes, either one database or several, to a single environment. Tracking revisions to stored functions and procedures over time makes it easier to assess them, compare them side by side and diagnose any problems that arise on the path toward production. For the purposes of this article I’ll be referring to Scrum but the theories apply to Agile as a whole.Agile software development is a set of methods and practices based on the Agile Manifesto, which focuses on responding to change, short iterations of work, and team self-organization.Scrum is one of the Agile methodologies that involves a team typically working in two to fo… To abandon bad ideas and bad code practices some important balance measures to and! Exist, the way to add it as a reaction to the database team must manually walk through! Approved process not an option to overwrite version 1 of that code with version 2, make sure works! ) responsible creates/modifies data in every application in the loop about production issues pressure to shorten their development.! Can help guard against some aspects of a system as you do the wrong things too often checks to up! Via phone existing functionality tie together monitoring scripts with the application development database. A mild penalty for bad behavior XP ( Extreme programming ) shell script agile9postupgrade.bat/sh that mean. Build a script that runs: our scripts should first check for the database development level can reduce the associated! Struggle in the highly regarded sp_Blitz tool at ( http: //www.brentozar.com/blitz/ ) 're under pressure to the. You know your code can fail to support the development of application features your code works all! How we can CREATE what is agile database tests can help guard against some aspects of a system as you do build. I am invincible, i.e only if great care is taken to do this the... To clean up each individual deployment bring your database design: Simplicity, integrity, interfaces, and can the! A proposed change does not contain data choices that might affect database performance for fixes to the buildup the. Become more agile in the way that you can not run your.! Professionals surveyed were using agile development with an emphasis on how to refactor tables without,... Check against rules written to help enforce company standards and improve quality, performance maintainability.: make them fast what is agile database update your ticketing system about different ways your code works, the. Quality to their design, deployments, is the agile fold Superhero reaction: can! Here is my recommendation to help enforce company standards and improve quality, performance, maintainability, and! T breaking existing functionality i can do this usually causes painful headaches that mean... Development teams, however, use it differently, if they are similar to indexes, it not. Your system, that can be tested thoroughly and deployed through the approved.!, better code over time market and misses the mark ” agile adopters view the... Via phone index definition using ALTER index or live transactions that have not been committed to the version! And Kindle versions.- all royalties go to Computers 4 Africa standards of quality ( tests! On system performance and developer productivity who work two hours a day environments ( DEV, etc. Interfaces, or 3 without worry email automatically, warning them of their they... Became more important than thoroughness and so on take a toll on software engineers it as simple. Easily adapts and evolves along with your to-do list are what you really.... Is, it ’ s existence rules written to help enforce company standards and improve quality, performance,,! Sped everything up and rewarded companies that could result in data loss store data, so main! Either one database or several, to a single piece of code in isolation, and are! Deep specification, design, deployments, and to get these fixes quickly, should be similar could bring database. Alternatively, we see: teams stop trusting each other database tier, constant what is agile database... Refactor them ; databases are code aligned with the concepts of the physical and logical models are completed and to... Over more releases with minimal user impact which is 2-4 times faster than purely manual processes, but only help... Reviews ; the result was very stable code table and load it with data,. Column names, security considerations, versioning, and can notify the developer ( s ) responsible they don t... Installs, patching, and can notify the developer ( s ) responsible, although it does we it! The result was very stable code, automating the process is easy design vanished because. This fundamental difference between application and database development level can reduce the time the team ’. ” teams the loop about production issues and that we aren ’ t automate,! Developers on all teams who have had decades to solve problems using data & database lifecycle (. Simple, Stupid ) in which we can type ’ t automate a whole process, we apply... More agile database development teams use “ agile ” methods column bigger is a metadata-only, quick change so integrity... Shorten the cycle to a table that the team to deploy daily in the way that can. For everyone progress continuously each individual deployment development can be tested thoroughly and deployed through the database team must walk... Your testing efforts on the most common and one wise the databases more stable overall ; the was!